Since federal brokers shot and killed a Minnesota ICU nurse in south Minneapolis on Saturday, high administration officers have made claims in regards to the encounter which are contradicted by bystander video and witness testimony.
These officers — together with a Cupboard secretary, a high White Home official and high regulation enforcement officers — have alleged, with out offering proof, that 37-year-old Alex Pretti needed to homicide brokers. They claimed that he attacked brokers, regardless of video proof on the contrary. They questioned his authorized proper to hold a hid weapon. They usually asserted that Pretti acquired fast take care of his wounds, although a witness mentioned in any other case.
Contemplate the claims, and the way they evaluate to video footage and witness testimony:
The declare: DHS says Pretti approached regulation enforcement with a handgun
Simply two hours after Pretti was shot and killed, a statement issued by the Department of Homeland Security claimed that he had “approached US Border Patrol officers with a 9 mm semi-automatic handgun.” The assertion mentioned brokers tried to disarm him, however he “violently resisted.”
What the video reveals: Bystander video reviewed by CBS Information shows Pretti holding a cellphone, not a gun, in his hand.
Display screen seize from CBS Information Minnesota video
A number of officers could be seen shoving Pretti to the bottom, then an officer in grey removes a gun from Pretti’s waist and runs from the skirmish whereas holding the gun. The primary shot is fired a few second later.
Display screen seize from CBS Information visible investigation 
What witnesses mentioned: In sworn statements, two witnesses mentioned they did not see Pretti brandish a weapon. One described seeing Pretti observing and filming the scene “simply together with his digital camera out. I did not see him attain for or maintain a gun.” One other mentioned she noticed a civilian “yelling on the ICE brokers, however I didn’t see him assault the brokers or brandish a weapon of any type.”
The declare: Kristi Noem, Kash Patel, Greg Bovino declare Pretti attacked officers
DHS Secretary Kristi Noem repeatedly claimed on Saturday that Pretti “impeded their regulation enforcement operations” and “attacked these officers.” Noem additionally asserted that Pretti arrived on scene “wishing to inflict hurt on these officers.” Border Patrol chief Greg Bovino mentioned Saturday that “this appears to be like like a scenario the place a person needed to do most harm and bloodbath regulation enforcement,” and on CNN Sunday, he insisted that Pretti had been “actively impeding and assaulting regulation enforcement.” FBI Director Kash Patel echoed these sentiments Sunday on Fox Enterprise, saying: “You don’t get to assault regulation enforcement officers on this nation with none repercussions.”
What video reveals: Movies of the scene main as much as the taking pictures present that Pretti was directing visitors and never interacting with federal officers till a girl close by was knocked down by an officer.
Display screen seize from CBS Information visible investigation of the Border Patrol killing of Alex Pretti 
When Pretti tried to assist her up, an officer sprayed him within the face with a chemical irritant, and different officers surrounded him and dragged him to the bottom. Movies present that Pretti was holding his mobile phone, not a gun, when he was approached by brokers.
Display screen seize from CBS Information visible investigation of the Border Patrol killing of Alex Pretti 
What witnesses mentioned: The 2 witnesses who submitted sworn statements described seeing Pretti shoved to the bottom. One mentioned: “It did not appear to be he was attempting to withstand, simply attempting to assist the lady up.” The opposite mentioned she did not see Pretti assault brokers, and noticed “completely no want for any violence, not to mention deadly drive by a number of officers.”
The declare: DHS says medics instantly rendered help
The DHS statement additionally claimed that “Medics on scene instantly delivered medical help to the topic,” a declare that was disputed by a pediatrician who rushed to the scene after she heard the gunshots.
What a witness mentioned: “Not one of the ICE brokers who had been close to the sufferer had been performing CPR,” the pediatrician bystander mentioned in a court docket declaration. As a substitute, she mentioned, the “sufferer was mendacity on his aspect and was surrounded by a number of ICE brokers” who “gave the impression to be counting his bullet wounds.”
The declare: Stephen Miller calls Pretti a “would-be murderer”
Pretti had no legal document however simply three hours after he was killed, White Home Deputy Chief of Employees Stephen Miller condemned him in a social media post as “a would-be murderer” who had “tried to homicide federal regulation enforcement.”
What the video reveals: Cellphone movies confirmed that Pretti didn’t have a gun in his palms earlier than he was pushed to the bottom by federal brokers. A number of movies from earlier than the taking pictures present that Pretti was holding a cellphone in his proper hand and nothing in his left.
The declare: Stephen Miller, Kristi Noem name Pretti a “home terrorist”
Miller known as Pretti a “domestic terrorist,” the identical time period he used to explain 37-year-old Renee Good after she was shot and killed by federal brokers in Minneapolis lower than three weeks in the past. Noem additionally accused Pretti of “home terrorism,” accusing him of needing to “perpetuate violence” for “ideological causes.”
Any supporting proof? Federal officers haven’t launched any proof to point that Pretti had plans to commit violence for ideological causes. In an interview with Fox Information on Sunday, Noem was requested for proof of her assertion that Pretti had violent motives. She declined to supply that proof, saying as a substitute that as “a part of this investigation, we’ll be listening to from these brokers and officers and folks on the bottom.”
The declare: Kash Patel says, “You can’t deliver a firearm, loaded, with a number of magazines to any kind of protest that you really want”
FBI Director Kash Patel recommended that Pretti had violated the regulation by bringing a weapon to the scene of a Border Patrol raid. “You can’t deliver a firearm, loaded, with a number of magazines to any kind of protest that you really want,” he said on Fox News. “It is that straightforward. You do not have that proper to interrupt the regulation and incite violence.” Bovino said on CNN that Second Modification rights “do not rely once you riot and assault…regulation enforcement officers.” And Noem mentioned: “I do not know of any peaceable protester that reveals up with a gun and ammunition slightly than an indication.” President Trump, too, weighed in, telling The Wall Street Journal: “I do not like every taking pictures. I do not prefer it. However I do not prefer it when any person goes right into a protest and he is obtained a really highly effective, totally loaded gun with two magazines loaded up with bullets additionally. That does not play good both.”
What the regulation says: Minnesota regulation permits carrying a handgun in public, offered you’ve a allow. Pretti has been described by native officers as a lawful gun proprietor with a allow to hold.
Response from gun rights advocates: These assertions from administration officers drew rebukes from gun rights advocates who usually discover widespread trigger with the GOP. “The Second Modification protects Individuals’ proper to bear arms whereas protesting—a proper the federal authorities should not infringe upon,” the Gun House owners of America posted on X. Rep. Thomas Massie, a Republican who respresents Kentucky’s 4th congressional district, wrote on X, “Carrying a firearm just isn’t a loss of life sentence, it is a Constitutionally protected God-given proper, and if you happen to do not perceive this you don’t have any enterprise in regulation enforcement or authorities.”
